CO129-068 - Sir Bowring - 1858 [5-12] — Page 308

?

one is related to the

Lovernor) refuse to give.

And he states

opinion. And

that even the

an

majority of

the Commissionvevere off opinion

that it would be

better to remove Mr. Caldwell from the Bench

it coved be done without

if it

hawhnefs.

this I

Now as to all have to observe that

neither the intention of the Commifuoin (which is wendy :negative as regards Mr Anday)

+

Aw

the two

the judgment of Members who from the

beginning

wew

hustite to

Livell

Mr Caldwell - no an

anithmetiere analysis of the hands of the tent (which

Even wee

it fair

world shew

nothing

nothing respecting the

established and de

305

Jes

importance of the cha

devriped) The five opinion of

the

fentlemen who had not

read the evidence on propriety of

the

Mr. Caldwell's

removal from the Bench-an the Commipaon

the opinion off

be

rexpearing his firms tole

a Justice of the Peace - ma

Mr Lynee (which

that of

is

very likly sound) that however useful in a subordinate capacity he

to the

was not equal to

conduct of a departmentă

na

finally

the circumstance:

that the examination

bren op home to him matters

servis blame and

of sever

suggests

*